Quick Conversion Table

Brand Equivalent Match
Anchor 43 close
Madeira 0513 close
Cosmo 245 close
Sullivans 45218 close
J&P Coats 3021 close
Dimensions 6019 close
Bucilla 6019 close
Candamar 6022 close

Hold a strand of DMC 816 up to a window on a bright afternoon and you'll understand immediately why this color carries a gemstone name. Garnet is not simply dark red — it's the red that exists in the space between burgundy and crimson, carrying the same depth of color as the January birthstone itself. The hex sits at a cool-leaning #970B23, which reads as almost wine-dark in poor light and blazes into deep ruby the moment strong illumination catches it. That dual nature is what makes 816 so endlessly useful on the needle.

A Color With Serious Historical Weight

Garnet red has been a prestige color across cultures for centuries. Medieval illuminated manuscripts used this shade of deep red to represent royal robes and sacred hearts. Victorian needlework patterns favored deep reds for their longevity — aniline dyes of the era were notoriously fugitive, but naturally mordanted garnet shades held fast in ways other colors could not. DMC has been producing thread in this family since the company's nineteenth-century origins, and the staying power of 816 in the modern line is a quiet acknowledgment that some colors simply work.

In contemporary cross-stitch, 816 pulls double duty. Designers call for it as a shadow color in red families, pairing it beneath DMC 321 (Christmas Red) to create dimensionality that flat red alone can never achieve. It also appears as the dominant red in traditionally-themed pieces — Celtic knotwork samplers, Scandinavian folk-art designs, and heraldic motifs all lean on this deeper, more complex red over a brighter alternative.

Working With Garnet on Different Fabrics

On white 18-count Aida, 816 appears at its richest — the white ground bounces light back through the thread, intensifying the gemstone quality. On natural linen or antique white evenweave, the warm undertones of the fabric cool the red slightly, nudging it toward a medieval tapestry feel that's genuinely beautiful in period-appropriate designs. If you're stitching a Renaissance-style piece or a piece that should feel aged and rich rather than bright and modern, 816 on linen over-two is worth trying before committing to a brighter red.

Stitchers working on dark fabrics — black or navy Aida — sometimes find that 816 doesn't pop as intended because its deep value is too close to the background. In those cases, moving up to DMC 815 (Medium Garnet) or even DMC 321 provides better visibility while keeping a similar hue family. Conversely, if you want a deep red that whispers rather than shouts on a dark ground, 816 with a blended needle alongside DMC 902 (Very Dark Garnet) creates a subtle, jewel-toned effect that's quite striking in ornament designs.

The Garnet Family and Palette Building

DMC structures a full garnet value range: 902 is Very Dark Garnet, 815 is Medium Garnet, 816 is simply Garnet, and 814 is Dark Garnet — the naming convention is slightly non-linear, but the color progression is real and worth understanding. For any design that needs shaded red — floral petals, ribbon bows, draped fabric — running through 814, 815, 816, and 815 again creates a believable gradient without needing to jump to an entirely different red family.

816 also works beautifully outside the garnet family. Paired with DMC 3371 (Black Brown) for outlining, it gives red elements a rich, warm edge rather than the harsh contrast of true black backstitch. Alongside DMC 3727 (Light Antique Mauve) and DMC 3726 (Dark Antique Mauve), 816 anchors a palette that reads as deeply Victorian — roses, plums, and garnets together. For Christmas designs, the classic pairing of 816 with DMC 890 (Ultra Dark Pistachio Green) and DMC 834 (Very Light Golden Olive) gives you Christmas without the commercial brightness of the typical red-green-gold trio.

Parking works particularly well with 816 in full-coverage pieces because the thread's deep, saturated color makes it easy to identify visually against both pale and dark fabric while you're tracking multiple active needles across a complex piece.

Garnet is a close but not exact match across brands, and the differences matter more than usual because this particular shade of deep red is one where slight variations in undertone are clearly visible.

Anchor 43 is the standard equivalent, but most stitchers who've worked with both describe the Anchor version as slightly more blue-purple in undertone compared to DMC's warmer cast. In large filled areas, this shows up as a color temperature shift — Anchor 43 reads slightly cooler and more formal, DMC 816 reads slightly warmer and more jewel-like. For most projects, either works beautifully, but if you're mixing brands within a single piece, avoid using both for garnet-family reds.

Madeira 0513 earns a "close" rating — their reds in this value range tend to be slightly brighter and more saturated than DMC equivalents. If you're using Madeira throughout a piece, the equivalent reads correctly in context. Problems arise when you try to blend or substitute Madeira for DMC mid-project.

Cosmo 245 and Sullivans 45218 are workable alternatives. Cosmo's thread tends to have a slightly silkier sheen than DMC, which changes how 816-equivalent red reads in the finished piece — shinier and slightly more coral in certain lights. Sullivans is generally reliable for this color family.

If you're genuinely out of 816 and can't order more, DMC 814 (Dark Garnet) is darker and will affect your shading relationships, while DMC 815 (Medium Garnet) is the closest value neighbor and is the most defensible emergency substitution within the DMC line itself.

Reference quality

How We Validate This Color Record

Use this page as a reference card for DMC 816: the structured data, quick conversions, and long-form copy are all tied back to the same stored color record.

Methodology
This page renders DMC 816, its hex value, and every brand equivalent from the site's source-of-truth color record, then checks long-form body copy against those same stored fields.
Verification status
Source-field checked. The page content is audited against the stored DMC number, brand equivalents, and match-quality labels before publishing.
Last reviewed
2026-04-20
Approximation warning
Screen hex values, thread photos, and cross-brand conversions are reference aids. Dye lots, thread sheen, and fabric color can still shift the result in hand.

Read the Stitchies methodology

Decision guide

When to use the DMC 816 reference page

This page should help you decide faster between palette planning, brand substitution, and shade comparison without turning the color record into a thin lookup page.

Best for

  • + Palette planning when you want the stored DMC 816 Garnet record, hex value #970B23, and linked brand equivalents in one place.
  • + Checking the quickest cross-brand shortlist before you buy floss, compare stash substitutes, or route into a more specific conversion page.
  • + Finding nearby shades in the reds family before you commit to accents, shading, or background blends.

Watch for

  • ! Screen previews are only reference aids. Garnet can shift on real fabric because thread sheen, stitch coverage, and room lighting change how the color reads.
  • ! A stored equivalent is still a shortlist, not a guarantee that two brands will disappear into each other in the same stitched motif.
  • ! Older charts, discontinued kit floss, and dye-lot variation can all introduce small but visible differences that the page cannot detect for you.

Before you commit

  1. Confirm the role of DMC 816 Garnet: decide whether you need an exact hero shade, a forgiving background, or a rough stash substitute.
  2. Compare on project fabric: view the skein or stitched sample on the same fabric count and color you will actually use.
  3. Use the linked conversion pages next: open the brand-specific pages when you need match-quality caveats before substituting away from the DMC reference.

DMC 816 FAQ

These questions appear on the page so the FAQ schema stays aligned with what visitors can actually read.

What is the Anchor equivalent of DMC 816?+

The closest Anchor equivalent to DMC 816 (Garnet) is Anchor 43. This is a close match.

What color is DMC 816?+

DMC 816 is called "Garnet" and has a hex color value of #970B23. It belongs to the reds color family.

What is the Madeira equivalent of DMC 816?+

The closest Madeira equivalent to DMC 816 (Garnet) is Madeira 0513. This is a close match.

How DMC 816 Looks on Fabric

The same thread appears different depending on your fabric. Always test on your project fabric.

DMC 816 on White Aida

White Aida

DMC 816 on Cream / Ecru

Cream / Ecru

DMC 816 on Black Aida

Black Aida

Pairs Well With

DMC colors commonly used alongside 816 Garnet.

Detailed Conversions

Where to Buy DMC 816

This section contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no cost to you.

Related Guides

Free Download

Free Printable Thread Conversion Chart

Pick a brand, enter your email, and we'll send you a printable chart mapping all 552 DMC colors to that brand's equivalents. Zero spam, one chart.

No spam. Your email is stored securely and never shared.